By a 4-3 vote, Milton Town Council elected to table a decision on whether to accept or reject the proposed Carey Farm annexation.
Carey Farm is a 192-acre tract on Shingle Point Road. Developer CD Carey Farms LLC is planning to build 242 single-family home lots and 143 townhouse units on the parcel. The land is currently in Sussex County, zoned AR-1, agricultural-residential, but if annexed, the developer is seeking an R-1 residential zoning with a large-parcel development overlay.
The Carey Farm parcel was reviewed by the town’s special review committee, which recommended moving forward with the annexation. But the committee had questions regarding the costs and benefits of allowing the parcel to be annexed.
Mallory Richards of PFM Management and Budget Consulting presented a cost-benefit analysis Sept. 8 showing the town would make $505,000 in revenues over the first five years, which would start in 2028 when the developer would start paying taxes on the land. On the expense side, the consultant estimated $473,000, for a net benefit to the town of $32,000. The main revenue from the development of land would be property tax and real estate transfer tax, while expenses are mainly personnel, such as police and maintenance. However, the committee had questions about those numbers and where they came from, specifically the reliance on the developer’s projections.
Milton’s annexation process calls for the application to return to town council after it has been reviewed by the committee. At council’s Oct. 5 meeting, council members had the choice of either approving or rejecting the committee’s report, or sending it back to the committee for additional review.
Councilman Robert Gray said the findings of the special review committee show the committee requested additional information regarding the sales pricing presented by the developer, the fiscal impact of the development and the capital expenses the town will incur. He said the committee report shows a slim margin of benefit and suggested sending the matter back to the committee to get the additional information they requested. PFM is working on an updated cost-benefit analysis.
Complicating things is that the special review committee has a limited timeline for its review per the town charter. Councilman Scotty Edler, a member of the committee, questioned how the timing would line up and why the matter needs to go back to the committee, since two of the three members – Edler and Vice Mayor Lee Revis-Plank – are on council. Town code mandates that after council accepts the special review committee’s report, council then sends the annexation request to the planning and zoning commission for review.
Town Manager Kristy Rogers said PFM is planning to present its updated cost-benefit analysis at council’s Monday, Nov. 2 meeting. So the problem for council Oct. 5 was trying to accept a report that does not have all the relevant information in it.
Mayor John Collier suggested council table its decision on accepting or rejecting the committee’s report until after the revised cost-benefit analysis is presented in November. Voting in favor of the motion were Collier, Gray and Councilmen Alan Pongratz and Perry Higgs, while Revis-Plank, Edler and Councilman Fred Harvey voted no.





