Share: 

The myth of by-right zoning

June 3, 2025

During the Sussex County zoning process, developers often claim they can develop a tract of land by right. They may even claim that public hearings are unnecessary, as the Cape Gazette reported May 6, which was then refuted by a letter to the editor from Bill Mailander May 13

The Sussex County zoning code does not mention by-right zoning. Rather, the zoning code section, Section 115-5, creates residential, business and commercial, industrial and flood-prone districts. The code and future land-use map establish the permitted uses in each district. These are permitted uses established by Sussex County Council, not the rights to build. The zoning code, Section 115-216, and state law also provide that council can change by ordinance the boundaries of districts and put conditions on the uses in those districts.

The Delaware Supreme Court has decided that while a county may not deny proposals that meet the code’s requirements, the county may condition its approval on the impact of land uses where those conditions bear a reasonable nexus to the impacts on the community. 

Lost in the claim of by-right zoning is that the zoning code, Section 115-3, provides that it requires the consideration of “present and future needs,” “lessen[ing] congestion in the streets or roads” and “adequate provisions of public requirements” for both urban and non-urban development. 

It is time to hold Sussex County and its developers to the requirement of adequate provisions for traffic, schools, emergency services, medical care, woodlands and the prevention of urban sprawl. This requirement emphasizes the need for balance in the decisions that impact all of us. No one has the right to develop property to the detriment of the greater community.

Jack Young
Rehoboth Beach
  • A letter to the editor expresses a reader's opinion and, as such, is not reflective of the editorial opinions of this newspaper.

    To submit a letter to the editor for publishing, send an email to viewpoints@capegazette.com. All letters are considered at the discretion of the newsroom and published as space allows. Due to the large volume of submissions, we cannot acknowledge receipt of each submission. Letters must include a phone number and address for verification. Keep letters to 400 words or fewer. We reserve the right to edit for content or length. Letters should be responsive to issues addressed in the Cape Gazette rather than content from other publications or media. Letters should focus on local issues, not national topics or personalities. Only one letter per author will be published every 30 days regarding a particular topic. Authors may submit a second letter within that time period if it pertains to a different issue. Letters may not be critical of personalities or specific businesses. Criticism of public figures is permissible. Endorsement letters for political candidates are no longer accepted. Letters must be the author’s original work, and may not be generated by artificial intelligence tools. Templates, form letters and letters containing language similar to other submissions will not be published.